United Kingdom


+44 121 266 4998




We share Gods love in various ways in our homes, places of work, local community, and throughout the world. Church life means faith, relationship, discipline, service, responsibilities of church leaders and members, and much more.

Nulla facilisi. Integer mollis, neque id consequat ornare, quam magna iaculis libero, a tristique est eros sit amet mauris. Ut porta nisl quis auctor dignissim. In hac habitasse platea dictumst. Maecenas vitae fermentum odio, ut commodo enim. Nam tincidunt aliquam felis, vel laoreet augue euismod nec. Nunc a ex at mauris auctor auctor. Cras ac velit aliquet, varius libero a, tincidunt eros.

Dialogue or Distraction?

35 years today, Sayyid Ruhollah Khomeini forced Reza Shah Pahlavi, the last monarch of Iran, to flee the country and led the country to an popular revolution, and a kingdom was transformed into the Islamic Republic of Iran. Today across the border, a very different kind of Islamic revolution is being attempted. The much anticipated dialogue between the Pakistani government and the Taliban have begun, and according to the leader of Pakistan Jamiat-e-Ulama-e-Islam (JUI), Samiul Haq, have been “positive”. His reluctance to share any details raises as many questions as it does answers, however I digress.

The question that needs answering is how and why Tehreek-e-Taliban Pakistan (TTP) are even being considered stakeholders in the future of Pakistan when they are the same people who have raped and plundered the country, blown up schools and mosques and beheaded soldiers. These are not mere allegations but the TTP have accepted responsibility for all this and more. The thought that these people are representatives of the Prophet (saw) who is considered “a mercy to the universes” is as abhorrent as it is laughable.

The 1973 constitution, while far from being perfect, enshrines in law all the civil rights, including freedom of thought and expression. The TTP have already shown that, under the guise of Shariah, they are willing to kill and maim people who disagree with them. If Musharraf deserves to be tried under Article 6 of the Constitution, TTP deserves to be hanged for rejecting the authority of the constitution outright. Instead, the Pakistani government is negotiating with them!

Imposing religion in a country that is already torn apart by religious extremism and sectarianism is like adding fuel to the fire. The criminals who are demanding Shariah are the ones who have taken responsibility for sectarian killings across the country. It is absolutely imperative in a heterodox country like Pakistan, which has complex division lines based on race, language and ethnicity as well as religious beliefs, that there is a form of government which allows this diversity to flourish by celebrating difference not shutting it down in the name of religion.

These negotiations are being held in the backdrop of continual killing of Shias, Christians and Ahmedis as well as other minority groups. The vast majority if not all of these attacks are carried out by the TTP. The government should be more concerned with bringing those responsible to justice instead of trying to brush this under the carpet by having a dialogue with those who have at no point offered any commitment to renounce violence.

People may point to the Good Friday Agreement in Northern Ireland or other such negotiations with terrorists around the world. The main difference in those cases and this one was a clear commitment to renounce violence, and to their credit, those groups while maintaining their position have indeed stopped carrying out terrorist attacks. There appears to be no willingness from the TTP to do so nor have the government at any point made this a condition of the dialogue. Yet the dialogue continues; we can only conclude from this that the government is keen to appease the political face of the TTP on whom it relies at the ballot box – the likes of Samiul Haq, Fazlur Rahman and Aurangzeb Farooqi.

In fact, dialogue is merely a distraction from the actual reason for the demand for Shariah, which is to simply grab power and territory under religious pretense. Previous governments led by the PML(N) have underlined that they are the political successors to the legacy of General Ziaul Haq’s Islamisation policies and today’s government is showing that nothing much has changed.

The only hope that Pakistanis have is to that the ballot box will speak loud enough that the majority of Pakistanis abhor TTP and their allies whichever guise they might take. But with free and fair elections being a pipe dream in Pakistan, this may be more hope than reality.

One response to “Dialogue or Distraction?”

  1. Hashim avatar

    Good analysis, Zafar, especially for pointing out what the mainstream media in Pakistan appears reluctant to name. Having said this, the piece follows the prevailing agenda & the narrative that is a journey to nowhere. The stark realities are that its the crooks and the criminals on both sides of the negotiating table, each party with their intentions for the power grab, and the real arbiters of power in Pakistan – the not-so-Pak Army – have yet to declare their hand. In the absence of a decision to wind up the strategic assets that have actually been liabilities for far too long now, all this is an exercise in rearranging the deck chairs. And its total subversion of the glorious religion when these agents of evil & darkness are given even an implied assent that they are the custodians of the Shariah. Far from it. Many of them deserve to be hung high if there truly was the rule of the Shariah for the Fisaad that they have unleashed. You hint at some of it but there is the need to break the tired moulds to shine a new light on these issues. I also object to the Shia being mentioned in the same phrase with other minorities. And there is also the minor issue of typos. Some one with a long pencil needs to edit the copy!